Newsletter
Resources
Courses
Books
Welcome to Emerging Futures -- Volume 271! Of Events / Of Creativity: 40 Key Concepts...

Good morning rich tendrilic becomings of events that are sweeping us into emergent futures – creative beyond knowing,
Over these past ten weeks, the question “what is an event?” has swept through us and swept us along – through storms, moments of being seduced by puffballs emerging, jumps into cold rivers rivering, feeling our way into plants blossoming, and joining the becoming of flight, and the middle way of soccering.
The concern of this series has been to speculatively and experimentally participate in a radical general re-orientation of how we approach both creativity and reality: it is a re-orientation to move us away from our historical Western and still all too prevalent approach (one that configures practices such that we sense and know creativity as human, individual, cognitive – reality as thing and essence focused – and where experience is divided away from reality: the really real which is “out there” and inaccessible versus what we subjectively experience). And to move us towards the perspective of the event.
To risk putting it too simply – it's an experimentation with two propositional lures: That…
These kinds of big arguments for the re-orientation of seemingly everything can often feel far removed from our everyday lives – that it's just more theoretical navel-gazing. And that shifting to a perspective that “everything flows” or “everything is related” – or “it’s all about complexity” might feel like they make for charming shifts in worldview – great for cocktail conversations and fireside chats – but that this all gets far too cosmic and too wishy-washy to make a meaningful difference in practice. One could rightly wonder: What difference will this actually make?
We, most certainly, don’t want this experiment to get pigeon-holed in the “cosmically cool, but of no practical value” category. For us, in our own work, these changes in practice and in daily life are very real and very concrete. Our hope is that this newsletter, in synthesizing the big concepts of an event perspective to reality’s creativity, can help you sense concrete possibilities in this experimental reorientation in your own lived everyday practices.
If waking up on this particular Friday, November the twentieth, was to be considered as participating in an astonishing event – one of these (many) that is exceptional, ongoing, complex and worth great attention is that the International Court of Justice has for the very first time found a state responsible for genocide. How this event further unfolds, what propensities emerge, and how this co-creates us – is something we are all of…
***
This ten-volume experiment has wandered over both familiar territory (assemblages, affordances, dispositifs, the transjective, worldmaking and more) – and made a path in walking towards new horizons (events, reorienting complexity, and a strong refusal of hylomorphism). It has been quite an oceanic passage – a global passage sailed in and of dynamic processual events – a journey undertaken without touching land (so to speak).
But now, on nearing a hospitable and welcoming port, we are taking stock of how we have been changed and with an occasional joy in the arbitrary – we gather forty of the concepts in a very provisional “carrier bag” of what we have picked up along the way – the odd sea shell, bits of flotsam, weavable roots, sharp stones, companion microbes, rhymes, a peculiar dance step, and a pattern of stars in the night sky – all that we have co-emerged with along the way. At some point in our journey, these became four containers – really four lures pulling us forward: what is an event? Why does this re-orientation matter? How does it change creativity? – and: What might we do differently? Not as best practices, or bombastic defensible trademarks, but as modest experiments in propositional lures for feeling…
Could we move from…
The first move of the re-orientation: we no longer start from a world of discrete things, individuals and their ideas – but from the middle of events, where everything, including us, is in its relational emergent becoming…
1. What is an event? Instead of asking what a thing “is” or who made it, we ask after the event: the relationally creative coming together of many ongoing processes such that they configure for some length of time to give rise to certain stable, active, emergent outcomes – which are themselves open creative processes.
An event perspective asks:
2. Everything begins (and remains) of the middle The enactive hunch that has taken hold of us over quite some time is that everything begins and remains of the middle. The middle of what? Events (of course) – and our own event logic is no exception, being itself an event in the ongoing becoming-otherwise. Our dear friend Madeline Gins (1941-2014) said it wonderfully, “being a human is an astonishing event.”
3. Creativity’s pronoun is “It” – as in “It is raining” or – it is mushrooming, it is souping, it is newslettering, it is four o’clock in the afternoon… Creativity’s pronoun is “it” – and it gifts us the preposition “of.”
Events: it individuates; we are of it… (so be it…)
4. Becoming-something (the hyphen matters) All things are “becomings” – becoming-somethings. The thing we call a mushroom is a process-event of coming into being, staying in being, and eventually becoming other things. Here the hyphen matters: becoming-something is a radically open, ongoing, and many-directional process – not a “becoming something” (an instance of a process reaching a prescribed conclusion).
5. Events are always also “becoming-other.” The processes that have configured to become a mushroom could have become something else – a becoming-peat, for example. The acorn is not destined to become a tree: when a wild pig comes along and eats it, the event-in-becoming creatively changes. What any becoming (event) means, and where it might go, is always an open question taken up by other becomings. No event has one becoming. It is endless transversals.
6. Everything flows – and? Everything flows: zoom in or out far enough, and rocks, mountains, tables and chairs flow – something long sensed in Daoist and Mahayana traditions. But flows are not everywhere the same – they differentiate, individuate, and some stabilize and persist (events). Events shift our perspective from an ever-flowing oceanic aether to a reality populated by intra-acting, semi-stable events across multiple scales.
7. The five-fold event From an event perspective, our processual intuitions are supplemented by a co-evolving feel for relations, emergence, historicity and difference – a five-fold event: process, relation, emergence, historicity, difference. Emergent outcomes cannot be traced back to any one source, and everything emerges historically – contingent, relational and dynamic. Everywhere, differences are ever differing – and this goes by another name: creativity.
8. Relations create what they conjoin Relations are no mere connections between stable pre-existing things – they are active transformative agents that make what is held in relation. A favorite example: we are not so much “in” love as “of” an active relational event of loving. Pick up a pen to write, and oilfields, forests, inks, upright bipedal hands and a thousand years of paper-making flow together through, in and of your actions.
9. Events all the way up, down – (and sideways) With events there is no scale that takes precedence over another; what gives shape to an event is always other events – “above,” “below,” and “beside” (as our creative companion in all of this, John Protevi says it). As foragers – a favorite example: The sideways, transversal injection of dust along with the sun’s energy and oceanic movement is what gives rise to the becoming-rain. As it rains, mushrooms emerge – and what are mushroom spores being released and drifting upward but dusts – collaborators in the very rain that conditions their own becoming…
10. Self-conditioning emergence (Becoming-Storm) A hurricane creatively individuates out of a series of precursor events joining and crossing immanent thresholds – and it persists only as long as certain energetic conditions are met. No single conditioning event gives rise to it. What if we viewed all innovations this way – as unfolding, self-conditioning, immanent events rather than individual cognitive achievements made real?
Why experiment with such a re-orientation at all? For us, it is because the classical approach – a bifurcated world of objective things and subjective experience – creatively shaped by immaterial plans (hylomorphism, the god model) is not a quaint superstition but a living event we are still very much of, built into our habits, tools and environments…
11. Of the event: reality is not “in” things The “same” Hudson River is an embracing liquid to a skilled diver standing fifteen feet above the river, and a terminally solid surface to a similar body falling from five hundred feet – and a tensile surface to a water-skimming insect. This is not a subjective shift – in each relational event, the water is what it is, and the moment you jump you are “of” it. What is real is not “in” anything (and certainly not in “H2O”) – it is the creative configurational achievement of an event, from which both the objective and the subjective co-emerge.
12. “Same” context, different events We need to extend the above example: Skiing and snowboarding, Polynesian and Western navigation, a woman and a man walking down the same Manhattan street: they are “in” the same context, but “of” very distinct events. None of these can be reduced to mere subjective experience, ways of seeing or invisible assumptions – that terrible condescending of “well, that is your experience…” or “that is one way to frame things”... Experience is not something added to the discrete objective givens of reality – it is reality – it is of an event...
13. Subjectings and objectings (becoming-soccer) Let's experiment further with an event: The event of soccering – field, lines, ball, rules, weather, habits, players – this relational and dynamic configuration co-creates its subjects (goalies, forwards) and its objects (offsides, goals) as semi-stable becomings. When the ball moves near your goal, no matter who you “are,” you are now “en-subjected” as a defender. There is no subject or object “in itself,” and nothing is passive: the ball is both provoker and recipient, endlessly flipped in the dance.
14. The “enminded” event Perhaps one most often feels “thinking happening inside of me” – in my head, in my “mind.” But if all things emerge from the middle of an open, distributed, more-than-human event, then perhaps it is the event that is “enminded” – and not my thinking that is embodied? Thinking moves through me as part of the co-animating force of an ever-evolving event.
15. Hylomorphism: Aristotle, considering how we engaged with things, and lacking a word for matter in general, coined the concept “hylomorphism” (wood + form): to articulate an “impositional creativity”: passive matter (“wood”) plus an active, immaterial forming plan. Its paradigm is brickmaking – the mold imposing its form on infinitely shapeable clay. It is still today the logic of creativity (Ideate, Plan, Impose). Yet anyone who has ever collaborated with clay knows there is no passive partner in this relational dance.
But this approach still remains today at the problematic configurational center of so-called creative processes…
16. Becoming-hylomorphic Gilbert Simondon (one of the critical complexity thinkers of the twentieth century – who is still sadly marginal in the (quite parochial) English-speaking worlds of the complexity sciences) noted that hylomorphism unconsciously inherits an impoverished social relation: the master who gives orders and the enslaved person who molds the bricks. Everywhere we begin with ideation, treat the plan as the source, or search for the hidden mindset, the DNA, the genius or the great leader – there is hylomorphism (and its profoundly problematic master-slave logic). We are still very much of the profoundly disturbing event of becoming-hylomorphic.
17. The god model (the becoming-god of classical creative practices) By the early Christian era, only god was creative: “Let there be light… and it was so” – here there is no process, no relations – full stop – end of story. Today we have simply brought this model to earth – substituting the transcendent idea with that of a human brain, DNA, or a “Theory of Everything,” – such that the so-called “creatives” of our era have become far too many little gods.
18. The zombie persistence of “ideas” If the relational conditions that configure an event persist, the event persists – even in the face of strong conceptual criticism – because criticism at the level of ideas does not change those conditions. To treat the “god model” as an abstract model is to fall under the spell of its very ideational logic. It too is an event: practices, tools, affects, values and environments – a “becoming-god” event that we are still of.
19. Architecting life “in our heads” Sidewalks, urban grids, traffic lights, rolling chairs, multiple screens, climate-controlled interiors, and Zoom calendars sequencing time into discrete units – and all participate in an emergent event of ideational subjectivity. These careful choreographic configurations are not incidental.
Our contrarian hunch is: shake our bodies and our sensibilities will follow.
What happens to creativity when we leave the god model behind? It is no longer a rare flash of individual brilliance, an idea made real – it becomes everywhere, more-than-human, distributed, and sourceless…
20. Flight invented them The classical story says the Wright brothers invented flight – but flight, in its own becoming, invented them. They became “of flight,” swept agentially into its becoming as helpmates, careful weavers and creative surfers – not originators. Like all innovations, flight was never magically invented by one act.
21. Events are always interesting A haunting of eventing led to the becoming of this entry, #21, vaporizing into the ether... Not sure where or when or why - but the becoming of the newsletter and in eventing delivering of "it" to your inbox at 8am EST today, requires that we accept all events as neither good, nor bad, but always interesting....
22. The myth of the solitary genius There is no Steve Jobs, or Da Vinci, or you or I alone. Even the great pairings – Fred and Ginger, Cage and Cunningham, Orville and Wilbur, Stein and Toklas, Harriet Tubman and Amiri Baraka – were never (just) two, but always a vast dynamic swarm of others. To focus on the one versus the two is to believe the myths and go no further.
23. More-than-human collaboration Collaboration is not something that already fully formed, autonomous individuals choose to enter into through considered discussion. Our lives – in every aspect – are the emergent outcomes of vast collaborative webs of coffee, traffic lights, winds, the curve of a hill, spell-checkers and kitchen knives. Individualism itself is the contingent historical outcome of specific constitutive collaborations.
24. Materials are active collaborators The wooden strut of an early plane was never just a handy lump of passive “material” to be shaped to a human vision. It grew relationally as a tree, and became a strut only through centuries of co-emergent know-how living in/of tools, forests, blacksmiths and workers attuned to the grain. Wood, metal, cloth and paint are real collaborators – with real relational agency in the process.
25. Leaving the cognitivist perspective The all-too-common equation “Inventor = Ideation = Innovation” approaches invention from a profoundly limiting perspective: that of the human and its cognition. From here, creativity becomes a battle of competing individuals and their ideas – whoever has the best one and executes fastest wins. But is innovation really best understood as a human cognitive activity, or encompassed by a focus on the “first”?
26. Innovation from the perspective of innovation (events) An experimental proposition: approach invention from a perspective immanent to its own emergent form-taking activity (an event) – not as a meta-human puppet master putting ideas into heads, nor as a way of filling some “lack” or solving some negative problem. Inventions individuate via the differential coming together of precursor conditions that they eventually exceed, taking on “a life of their own.” Invention is always a generative process of world-making (that we are actively of).
27. The event creates itself Getting personal: This fall, when picking a giant puffball mushroom at the forest edge, I was pulled into a creative “becoming-with” – trimming, slicing, sautéing – more pulled along than leading the dance (and till late in the process not even knowing it would all become a soup). My mother’s foraging, the forest, a stove, the cold evening – so many prior event processes swarming through all of “us” – prepared us all to find each other. It would not feel right to say “I created a wonderful mushroom soup”: the event, in its open configuring across thresholds of irreversible becoming, created itself (and me as a chef…).
28. No seed, no source, no plan Dust is often described in the scientific literature as the “seed” of rain, but that can make it feel far too automatic and plan-following. Rain is the coming together of dusts, wind, gravity, oceans, land masses, and even traffic jams (smog) – in the right relative sequence with the right relational intensities. There is no seed, source, or plan that events follow…
29. Planless patterns The Greeks believed that they found the Golden Ratio “in” the spirals of plants and they took this as proof of a hidden, ideal, immaterial source directing the growth of these patterns. But as countless experiments in the complexity sciences have demonstrated – there is no plan, no secret mathematics – rather, it is “just” the immanent relational dynamics of growth. The event is creating itself…
30. What if there is no center? What if then there is no silver bullet, no smoking gun, no guru, no genius – what if it is the configuration itself, as a dynamic mutable configuration, that is the “source” of creativity? Genes, plans, ideas and charisma all do matter – just not in the starring causal role we imagined. They too are relational participants, made by the events they co-create…
The classical, problematic approach to creativity and reality persists not as an idea or a mindset or an invisible assumption – but as an ecology of practices – because of this – this re-orientation cannot be postulated as a mere change of mindset, or an emancipatory re-framing. What we are curious about is not a new set of best practices – but experimental configurations and propositional lures for co-creating the conditions in which we, and the new, might become radically otherwise.
31. Begin from the present – not an imagined future As Erin Manning put it to us: the problematic contemporary style of creativity places far into an imaginary future and moves from there forward, abstractly – never touching the actual of the present. As such any novel emergent event is “strangled before it can gestate.”
An alternative style perturbs the present collaboratively towards experimenting with a critical incessant and ever multiplied and repeated question: “what else is possible?”
32. The only way elsewhere is through We cannot come to anything “new” if we are always already becomings-of a lived ecological history (with one (very active) foot in the old). Rather, we must experiment in two seemingly contradictory directions at once: grasping a co-creative reality, and grasping how we are of a worlding that keeps us from sensing it. The way through is loopy – we are pulled into a future-in-the-making while looking back.
33. Change the conditions – not just the idea Here we are experimentally “following” Deleuze and Guattari, “wherever there are habits there are concepts”: co-animated ecological habits give rise to concepts, which in turn co-shape the ecology of habits. If we sense that “thinking is in the head,” then the reason is to be found in a robust ecology of sidewalks, screens, chairs and calendars – not in personal failings. So the work is to experimentally reconfigure environments, tools and practices, looping outward from abstractions into the lived ecologies that give rise to them.
34. Soften the haunting of critique A critique that stays at the level of denunciation: no more elephants! no more icebergs! no more linearity! – can ironically reinforce the very event it wishes to escape. And – how is it anyone’s fault to be born into this world and to have become of its ecosystemic logics? Criticism needs caution, care, humility, compassion for the event, curiosity and joy – in almost equal measure.
35. Offer novel propositions as lures for feeling For anyone schooled in the West, a proposition is “a statement put forward for consideration, acceptance or rejection” – the negative already haunting the “is.” Yet no statement is ever merely for acceptance or refusal: every act is a probe into the new. Here we are experimentally with Alfred North Whitehead – what if propositions act as experimental lures for feeling – drawing us into the co-creative becoming of an event?
36. Let the new – be new The new never lands on a blank slate; it emerges into an agentially full world that co-creates it as a “contrast to be judged” – does this do that better – does it help with my problem? – and so it is pulled into places already waiting for it – TED talks, workshops, augmentations to consultants' heavily branded models.
We contrast this with approaching the new as an open, non-comparative – and as-yet-unknowable becoming-different-in-kind.
37. Stop peeling (and layering) the onion An anti-creative essentialism peels away the superfluous, layer by layer, to get down to an unchanging core – it is what we, as lovers of the kitchen, call “the onion approach.” And far too many alternatives (especially in the complexity sciences) continue this problematic logic – moving from the “simple” to the “complicated” to the “complex” – simply adding layer after supplemental layer to the center. So – here too is a problematic onion, just going the other way – how the onion haunts us too!
38. Practice criticism as a minor art Again, here we experimentally follow Deleuze and Guattari: “minor” and “major” are not questions of scale but of operational logics. A major art fixes, stratifies, codifies and encloses; a minor art is an immanent experimental practice for the co-emergence of the new. Criticism as a minor art helps us bend our co-creative loops a bit more towards becoming collectively otherwise (we are doing our best to avoid criticism as a Majoritarian practice).
39. Sense complexity everywhere Complexity is too often enacted as a circumscribed zone – non-linear, emergent behaviors found only in a limited set of circumstances “in the wild.” This, too, is beholden to historical ecologies of linear, mechanistic, human-centric sensing. Our event-based curiosity is towards experimenting with a reality that is everywhere complex: relational, dynamic, loopy and co-creatively emergent.
40. Presence is a practice This is where the re-orientation lands – as our colleague in the WorldMakers community, Katrina Donald reminds us: “Presence is a practice.” We are not pre-existing subjects moving into contexts and looking out at a separate objective world – we are of events, and we come creatively into being through, of and as further events. Shifting how we sense, feel, do and know thus becomes the experimental co-creating of novel configurational events – an ontogenetic question, not merely an epistemological one.
And so this is the propositional lure of the whole series: what might happen if we stop beginning with the human, the individual, the idea, and the logic of god-like creator – and to begin, again and again, from the middle of the event?
This is not because the classical approach is simply “wrong,” but because it too is an event we are (problematically) of – and only by ever ongoingly experimentally co-creating different configurations of habits, tools, environments and practices – can we become radically otherwise.
Creativity is not something we have – it is something we are of…
Until next week
Keep Difference Alive,
Jason and Iain
Emergent Futures Lab
+++
P.S.: The question we hear most often from newsletter subscribers is: How can I participate more deeply in this work?
We have two ways:
1. Emerging Futures+ is where the newsletter becomes alive: post your comments, questions, or thoughts alongside practitioners across five continents, connecting each volume to their own work. Plus the extended audio version for a commute, join 2 live events per year, and the full searchable 270+ volume newsletter archive.
🧨 Start with a $1 trial for 7-days… Then $6/month or $60/year. Cancel anytime.
2. WorldMakers is where the newsletter gets practiced. Facilitators, educators, consultants, and researchers experimenting with emergence and change-making. In dialogue, in shared experiments, in the collaborative making of a different approach to creativity. Members have access to everything in Emerging Futures+, plus thirty-five live events a year, two weekly podcasts, bi-weekly creativity exercises, and the complete annotated bibliography.
💥 Start with a $1 trial for 7-days… Then $60/month or $597/year. Cancel anytime.
